Comparison of SRTM and O/S Land-Form Panorama DEMs

General TransDEM topics, not covered by other forums
Post Reply
Message
Author
geophil
Posts: 1516
Joined: 05 Jan 2011 16:45
Contact:

Comparison of SRTM and O/S Land-Form Panorama DEMs

#1 Post by geophil »

British Ordnance Survey started a free geo data initiative in early 2010. Among the data sets offered we find a DEM type which is called "Land-Form PANORAMA®". Originally published as a vector map of contour lines it is now also available as a raster map, in two different file formats.

Don't expect sensations, horizontal resolution is 50 m, but this is still about twice as good as 3 arc sec SRTM. I would expect that UK route builders will switch over to this new free DEM source in the future. It required enhancements in TransDEM, though.

TransDEM supports O/S Land-Form Panorama DEMs in ESRI grid format from Version 2.1. Before, TransDEM could only read this format if the coordinates were geographic (lat/long). I extended the ESRI grid reader to also support projected coordinates. Since the coordinate system is not part of the meta data information in the file, it must be specified in TransDEM explicitly. In this case coordinates are O/S grid (OSGB36).

Land-Form Panorama is organised in tiles. Each tile is 20 x 20km. File hierarchy and naming uses the two letter O/S grid square codes:
OSGridSquares

I have added an option to the TransDEM status bar to display the grid square code, see screenshots below. This will be helpful to identify the DEM tiles needed for a project.

Let's compare SRTM 3 arc sec, rendered as a 60 m grid (it is actually 60 x 90 m), with 50 m Land-Form Panorama. The location is the Pennines, River Calder valley, near Hebden Bridge in Yorkshire. Firstly, a standard DEM view with shading turned on.

Image
Image

The sharper image is Land-Form Panorama.

Secondly, a comparison of contour lines. The topographic map in the background is the 1:25000 O/S "Explorer".

Image
Image

Land-Form Panorama contours provide the better match.

At last, an orthophoto of the valley bottom, this time with Land-Form Panorama only. Nothing exceptional again, but I guess, it's well worth a try.

Image


[Post copied from the Auran forum]
Damien_Zhar
Posts: 34
Joined: 10 Jan 2011 11:31
Location: Moscow, RU
Contact:

Re: Comparison of SRTM and O/S Land-Form Panorama DEMs

#2 Post by Damien_Zhar »

How does this new data compare to GDEM? I believe the GDEM has a resolution of 20 metres or so. And that's why I found this phrase funny
I would expect that UK route builders will switch over to this new free DEM source in the future.
- aren't we expected to use the data that fits our tastes best?
Post Reply